Evenmile Insurance Briefing
The Collision vs. Comprehensive Dilemma
Reading Time: 4 minutes • Target Audience: Policyholders
with vehicles aged 5+ years
1. Key Executive Takeaway
As automobile repair costs increase nationwide due to
advanced driver assistance sensors (ADAS) and composite
structural parts, many vehicle owners consider
increasing physical damage deductibles to balance yearly
policy payments. However, failing to compare your
vehicle's actual cash value (ACV) against these
deductibles often leads to negative returns.
The Rule of Ten
Percent
If the combined annual cost of collision and
comprehensive is more than about 10% of your car's
actual cash value minus your deductible, consider
dropping them, as long as the car is paid off and you
could afford to replace it. Putting the savings toward
higher liability limits often protects you better.
2. State Highlight: Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement
Standard auto policies pay a totaled car's actual cash
value, meaning its market value just before the loss,
not what you paid or what you still owe. Unless you have
gap coverage or an agreed-value endorsement, the payout
won't cover a remaining loan balance or most aftermarket
parts.
-
Glass breakage: Check whether
comprehensive in your state carries a mandatory
zero-deductible glass clause (common in FL, KY, and
SC).
-
Animal strikes: Under standard
policies, hitting a deer or other animal is covered
by comprehensive, not collision.
-
Storage charges: Verify your
policy cap for post-accident vehicle storage
yards.
Recommended Next Step
Review Section D of your policy declaration sheet.
Check if your collision deductible matches your
available liquid emergency savings.
Evenmile Insurance Briefing
Uninsured Motorist Endorsement Audit
Reading Time: 3 minutes • Target Audience: Commuters and
multi-vehicle households
1. The Coverage Deficit in Urban Corridors
While state requirements stipulate mandatory liability
limits, the Insurance Research Council estimates that
15.4% of U.S. drivers, more than one in seven, were
uninsured in 2023. An Uninsured Motorist (UM) and
Underinsured Motorist (UIM) endorsement protects you
when the at-fault driver has zero or insufficient
limits.
Stacking
vs. Non-Stacking Policies
In states that permit stacking (such as Florida and
Pennsylvania), you can combine the UM limits for each
vehicle insured under your policy, multiplying your
bodily injury recovery cap in serious incidents.
2. Property Damage vs. Bodily Injury
UM coverage divides into two distinct riders: UMBI
(Bodily Injury) and UMPD (Property Damage). In states
without UMPD provisions, hit-and-run vehicle damage must
be routed through your collision coverage, subjecting
the payout to your standard collision deductible.
-
Hit-and-Run Protocol: Many
policies require you to report a hit-and-run to
police promptly, often within 24 hours, before an
uninsured motorist claim will be paid.
-
Passenger Safeguards: UM coverage
usually also protects relatives who live with you,
including when they ride in someone else's
car.
Evenmile Insurance Briefing
State Tort Thresholds & Lawsuits
Reading Time: 5 minutes • Target Audience: Cross-state
motorists and relocation planners
1. Fault Jurisdictions vs. No-Fault Systems
Understanding your legal standing after an accident
requires knowing whether your state uses a traditional
at-fault (tort) system or a no-fault system. In no-fault
states (like Michigan, New York, and New Jersey),
Personal Injury Protection (PIP) pays your immediate
medical bills regardless of who caused the crash.
Verbal vs. Monetary Tort
Limits
In verbal threshold states, you can only file a
lawsuit for pain and suffering against an at-fault
motorist if injuries meet defined statutory criteria
(e.g. permanent impairment or significant
disfigurement).
2. Driving Out of State
Most policies include an out-of-state coverage clause
that raises your limits to meet the minimums of the
state you're driving in, and can add required coverage
such as PIP.
-
PIP Medical Limits: Range from
$10,000 in Florida to unlimited medical benefits
under Michigan's tier structure.
-
Subrogation: After paying your
claim, your insurer can seek reimbursement from the
at-fault driver, and you may get your deductible
back.