We use cookies to analyze site traffic, optimize your experience, and provide relevant insurance insights. Read our Cookie Policy to learn more.

Cookie Preferences

Strictly Necessary

Essential for page navigation, security, and fundamental website features.

Analytics Cookies

Help us understand how visitors interact with insurance calculators and guides.

Marketing Cookies

Used to show personalized policy guides and insurance tips.

Free Tool

Should I Drop Full Coverage on My Car?

Compare what collision and comprehensive cost with the most they could ever pay out, using the 10% rule.

Is collision and comprehensive still worth it?

Compare what the coverage costs with the most it could ever pay out.

$
Use a private-party value from a pricing guide such as Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds.
$
Find it on your policy declarations page. Not sure? Estimate it from your state.
Do you have a car loan or lease?
Could you afford to replace the car if it were totaled?
Our take

  • Most the insurer would pay
  • Yearly cost as % of that
  • Years of premiums to equal one payout

Rule of thumb: consider dropping collision and comprehensive when they cost more than about 10% of what the insurer would pay if the car were totaled, as long as the car is paid off and you could replace it yourself. This is general information, not advice.

The state estimate scales the statewide average cost of collision and comprehensive by your car's value, with a floor because even older cars cost something to insure. Your own price will differ. See our methodology.